I had no idea the film and book Edythe were so different! I'm not quite sure why they felt the need to make a villain out of her. I can't imagine it saved that much screen time. As for Joe, I nearly melted in my seat when he and Gwenivere were dancing and he referenced their prior conversation at the fashion show. He followed it up with a comment about her being dolled up and looking quite different didn't change the shape of her body or the depths of her eyes. ::faints::